LONDON — The sight of a car limping along on a near-flat tire, or a roadside wheel change are still common.
So is the expense of replacing tires that have worn out prematurely, perhaps because the driver may not have been checking the pressure as regularly as they should.
Sometimes it's difficult not to feel tires are a car's weak link. But is this about to change?
Is it the end of the black rubber air-filled doughnut first used on vehicles in the 1890s - a product designed to be indestructible, and therefore not easy to recycle?
On a test track in Luxembourg, a Tesla Model 3 is twisting through tight corners, accelerating rapidly, and doing emergency stops. Standard stuff. What's remarkable, though, is the car is sitting on four airless tires — made by Goodyear, the US manufacturer.
Michael Rachita, Goodyear's senior program manager for non-pneumatic tires (NPTs), is upfront about the limitations: "There will be noise, and some vibration. We're still learning how to soften the ride. But we think you'll be surprised at the performance." He wasn't wrong.
Electric cars and autonomous mobility are changing tire needs. Delivery firms and shuttle services want products that are low-maintenance, puncture-proof, recyclable, and have sensors that map road conditions.
Car sharing and ride-hailing, rather than ownership, are rising in cities. A car with a flat tire is a car not making money.
Rachita says: "While air-filled tires will always have their place, a mixture of solutions is needed. As we move into a world where autonomous vehicles are becoming more common and many cities are offering transport-as-a-service strategies, having a maintenance-free tire is hugely important."
At Michelin's labs, the tires are tested for 24 hours at a time, under different loads and speeds. That's thousands of miles non-stop. Some spokes deform, some break, but the structures continue to perform safely, Rachita says. "It's test-learn, test-learn," he says. "But we're at a stage that's given us a huge amount of confidence. This is the real deal."
Goodyear rival, Michelin, has been working with General Motors (GM) on airless tires since 2019. In February there were media reports that Michelin's Unique Puncture-proof Tire System (Uptis) could debut on a new Chevrolet Bolt electric car being planned by GM, possibly as early as 2024.
Uptis tires are made of high-strength resin embedded with fiberglass and composite rubber (for which Michelin has filed 50 patents) to create a mesh structure that surrounds an aluminum wheel.
Cyrille Roget, a scientific and innovation expert at the French tire maker, won't confirm the Bolt reports, but tells the BBC Michelin will have more to say later this year.
Michelin has been a market leader in airless wheels. Its Tweel (tire-wheel) has been around since 2005 and is used on slow-moving vehicles, such as farm equipment.
Optimising the technology for road vehicles is, however, a totally different challenge, Mr Roget says: "We have 130 years of experience and knowledge in perfecting inflatable structures like pneumatic tires. Airless technology is very recent."
Uptis, though, is just a step to something bigger. The company that gave us the pumped-up Michelin Man logo, has a multi-year plan, to create a tire that is airless, connected, 3D-printed and made entirely of materials that can be melted down and re-used.
Apart from occasional re-treads, it would be zero-maintenance, according to Michelin.
Heavy battery weight means airless structures are particularly suited to electric vehicles. "You can carry more load with a more compliant feel than in an air tire," Rachita says.
On the other hand, airless tires have a greater contact patch with the road, increasing the drag. This rolling resistance uses more energy to drive the tires forward - with implications for battery life and range.
And then there's noise - the hum of rubber-on-road.
"With engine sound removed on an electric car, tires become the dominant source of noise," says Matt Ross, editor-in-chief of Tire Technology International.
In addition, the rigidity of plastic spokes transmits more vibration through the suspension. Drivers long used to the response and performance of air tires could take some convincing, he feels.
More important than consumer perception, however, is what regulators decide.
Governments will demand rigorous safety tests and a standardisation of rules. And tire makers will need to invest heavily in new manufacturing facilities and develop supply chains. It will take years.
Tire makers hope early adopters in niche areas will help drive the technology forward. "Non-pneumatic tires (NPTs) are of particular interest to sectors like the military, disaster response, security vehicles, and specialist machinery," Klaus Kraus, head of European research and development at Hankook, tells BBC News.
The South Korean company unveiled the latest version of its i-Flex NPT in January. Smaller than a conventional tire, a honeycomb of interlocking polyurethane spokes is a breakthrough in coping with lateral and horizontal stresses, the company says.
Bridgestone, the world's largest tire maker, is interested in industrial applications in farming, mining and construction, where demand could be high from customers that see a costly loss of productivity when tires fail.
Airless tires will, initially at least, carry a premium price. But the ability for regular re-treading and 3D printing could be a game changer. Maybe, some experts speculate, consumers won't even need to buy tires outright. Instead, they'll get them free and pay-per-mile, with sensors monitoring usage.
It's an illustration of where the technology is taking the tire of the future, says Sosia Causeret Josten, an analyst at Goodyear's Sightline Tire Intelligence division. As the only contact between the road and the vehicle, tires offer huge potential.
Perhaps, thanks to cloud computing and algorithms, connected vehicles could deliver information about where government authorities need to make road repairs or lay grit during freezing weather.
Take another example, automatic braking systems. "If the anti-lock braking system (ABS) can tell that the vehicle is driving on half-worn summer tires, it can react quicker. This advantage can play an important role in an autonomous future, where the vehicle has to react itself," she says.
Not all this tech need be exclusive to airless tires, or course. And not all manufacturers are convinced NPTs are the future. "To this day, we believe that pneumatic tires are the best choice for most vehicles," says Denise Sperl, a director of car tire research and development at Germany's Continental.
Tires will always need "to simultaneously meet multiple requirements for safety, comfort, performance and sustainability" and air-filled rubber remains the best compromise, she says.
Continental is developing a self-inflating system where pumps and sensors in the wheel keep the pressure at optimum levels.
Like all manufactures, the company is looking into "greener" products. Polyester from recycled plastic bottles will soon be used in its premium tires, and both Continental and Goodyear are researching a dandelion flower that produces latex similar to rubber trees.
But sustainable alternatives to conventional materials are available only "to a limited extent," Ms Sperl adds. Air tires have been around so long for a reason - they do the best job. "We remain convinced of this," she says. — BBC
